Which movie should I watch?

No (very) recent ones.
Not too old.
No over the top comedies. (college films etc.)
No obvious ones, like The Matrix, Lord of the Rings (seen them all,
almost).
Over 6-6.5 on IMdB

Sorry if I seem too picky. But I watch a lot of movies so I know what
I'm in to. Chances are that out of your suggestions I probably already
seen 90% of them. I'm looking for that special gem but not too indie
or "movie-connoisseur'y". Kinda' like Taken --- a movie a randomly
stumbled upon which I'm amazed as to why it didn't get better
marketing and widerrecognitionn...

Thanks!!!